First of all, a quick welcome back after my May holiday.
But now there is business.
In the ODI series against New Zealand so far – admittedly not the mot important series – England have been fairly pathetic.
But I am not going to pass this by as a simple, momentary lapse in concentration with minds more focused on the Champions Trophy. No.
I think the two performances are proof of deep fissures in this England ODI side.
Although injuries give the bowling some pardon, the English batting should take a huge amount of criticism. So far, it has exhibited the kind of poor shot selection which has become England’s bane throughout the formats recently.
Players have seemed too desperate to score quickly that they have forgotten to stay in. Indeed, England excelled in terms of run-rate in the most recent game against NZ. At the point when they were bowled out by the Kiwis, England had amassed more runs than NZ had at the same time.
The promise this shows makes the loss all the more disappointing.
I blame this to being toned into a ‘T20’ kind of mode, and in part I blame this to the coach selection. I think there should be separate 50 and 20 over coaches, if just to help the players mentally.
So my solution to the batting problem is the above, but also a changing in batting personnel and order. Here is my proposed England batting line-up (this includes KP’s injury).
Alaistair Cook
Ian Bell
Jonathan Trott
Eoin Morgan
Joe Root
Matt Prior
My explanation for this I will attempt to fit into a few points.
Big-hitters must be alternated. Of course, the ideal batting set-up in the middle, especially in limited-overs, is to have one man anchoring and amassing runs via singles, twos and threes, while another man – or perhaps a succession of men – hit the bowlers around and out of the park.
All rounders are pointless. I really think there is no use for an all-rounder, especially with a five-man bowling attack in force. This is reinforced by England’s current lack of in-form, quality all-rounders; none of Samit Patel, Chris Woakes and Ravi Bopara really inspire the imagination. If you play fifty overs, that suits perfectly – five bowlers bowling ten overs each. And if one really messes up, you always have Root and Trott to turn to.
Prior must play. When the best wicketkeeper/batsman is available to you – and one with a ridiculously high run-rate in Tests, good skills with the gloves and a talent for leadership – you do not leave him out of ODIs. Especially when you consider the alternatives: Jonny Bairstow and Jos Buttler (unrefined, weak handling and unreliable batting) and Craig Kieswetter (majorly out of form).
And now I turn to bowling.
It was really poor against New Zealand.
Jade Dernbach and Chris Woakes leaked runs like a colander, while wickets were sorely missed from Tim Bresnan.
I think the main problem for England here is depth.
With Broad and Finn out, England look crippled, not only bowling, but as a side in the whole.
But this is an unrepairable issue, so I turn to another main problem.
I think the England selectors have given Dernbach and Woakes too many chances.
They cannot afford to carry men.
Even an unproven player like Stuart Meaker, Boyd Rankin and so on would be a better alternative to that troublesome duo.
I am troubled.
Joe